Screen Shot 2016-08-19 at 12.16.19

As LNG partner New Fortress Energy begins shipment of liquefied natural gas to the island, power distributor Jamaica Public Service Company (JPSCo) is indicating that savings will depend on pricing, which varies from month to month.

Chief Financial Officer of the Jamaica Public Service Company (JPSCo) Dan Theoc told the Jamaica Observer: “The cost of LNG at Bogue is likely to be cheaper than the cost of oil next month (September) when Bogue is expected to come on line.”

But, based on current price differentials and the fact that Bogue will only represent approximately 12 to 15 per cent of the generation mix, it is expected that total savings — based on this price differential – will be marginal (less than five per cent), all other things remaining equal, Theoc told the Business Observer.

Spot prices for LNG on the Henry Hub (HH) index registered US$2.82 per million Btu in July after starting the year at US$2.28 in January and falling to US$1.73 in March.

Crude, on the West Texas Intermediate index, started the year at US$30.32 per barrel and crested at US$44.65 in July.

“Unfortunately, we cannot say definitively what the impact of natural gas will be in the future because of the volatility in oil prices relative to natural gas prices,” Theoc said.

JPS will be buying natural gas from Fortress under a 20-year exclusive gas supply agreement and they will be responsible for all of the supply chain logistics and infrastructure costs.

That includes the mode of delivery to the island, the frequency of delivery, the storage of the LNG, the regasification and the distribution by pipeline to the property.

Theoc noted, “We will pay for gas based on the Henry Hub Index plus an agreed margin (which we cannot disclose), similar to how we buy fuel today from Petrojam based on the US Gulf Average Mean Index plus an agreed margin.”

In general, he added, “It is worth noting that the HH index in the past five years has been far less volatile compared to Oil-based Indices (like US Gulf, WTI and Brent Crude), so we view the move to HH as being a plus for price stability.”

It is expected that Bogue will actually make up 12 to 15 per cent of the generation mix on natural gas and that when the 190MW plant in Old Harbour comes on line in 2018, approximately 40 per cent of our generation mix will be based on gas-fired power plants.

In general, it is expected that renewables penetration will increase from five per cent in 2015 to 12 per cent by 2018.

The consequence, Theoc said, will be an improvement in fuel diversity from a situation where 95 per cent of production was oil-fired last year to a situation where less than 50 per cent is fired by oil.

The CFO said the pending award of a gas project to Jamalco will also potentially increase the percentage of generation units which are fired by natural gas by about ten per cent to further replace oil-fired units by 2019.

Jamaica Observer 

Winston Hay, energy consultant and former director general of OUR. - Ian Allen/Photographer
Winston Hay, energy consultant and former director general of OUR. – Ian Allen/Photographer

Avia Collinder, Business Writer

Energy consultant Winston Hay says that while plans for use of LNG for power generation in Jamaica are in principle sound, the uncertainty around the cost of that fuel should not be ignored.

LNG is now selling at record prices in Asia where Japan as a top consumption market reportedly pays the highest price.

Hay, who was once the head of the Office of Utilities Regulation (OUR), said that application of relatively new technology – fracking – in the United States has led to greater extraction of “shale gas” at greater depths than had previously been exploited.

And it has dramatically decreased the price of natural gas in that country.

But the stability of those prices is uncertain and the Henry Hub price reports have already begun to show a significant upward trend, he said.

Production doesn’t affect price

Importantly, he adds, the price of LNG does not vary directly with natural gas production costs.

Flammable gasses trapped in the earth and consisting primarily of methane are found in many areas of the world – the Middle East, Russia, Nigeria, Australia, Nigeria and North America, for instance.

LNG has been used for decades as a source of heat for industrial processes, cooking, household heating, and other uses, but only in relatively small quantities for electricity generation until about the late 1960s, with development of the combined-cycle technology.

“The aggregate costs of delivering the gas to the liquefaction facility, the liquefaction process itself, transport by specially constructed vessels to the FSRU, operational costs of the FSRU and Jamaica Gas Trust, delivery by pipeline (yet to be constructed) to the end-users, etc, will all increase the price of gas from LNG significantly above that of the gas extracted from the earth,” Hay said.

Further, he notes, commodity prices are not necessarily determined by production costs.

“The demand-supply ratio is often more significant. The indications are that the demand for LNG internationally will steadily increase and therefore apply upward pressure on the prices of that commodity,” he said.

Several worldwide developments, he said, are likely to push LNG prices higher: